Susan, daughter of Henry and Susannah Smith Hill, was born August 27, 1837. She was married previously to John C. Booker on November 3, 1852 in Kanawha County and after Allen's death married Thomas M. Arthurs on February 6, 1879 in Clay County, West Virginia. The children born to Allen and Susan were: Levi Bascom, b. August 24, 1861, d. January 15, 1918, m. Susan M. Moore January 17, 1882; Adaline V., b. ca. 1865, m. Henry F. Cline, December 23, 1885, m. Samuel Camp; James Anderson, b. March 16, 1868, d. January, 1932, m. Malinda Belle Dawson, November 8, 1894, married again, name not known; Selina M., b. August 22, 1866, m. Francis M. Reed; Jerusha Adaline, b. May 1, 1870, d. February 24, 1937, m. Marshal Clark Friend; William H. Harrison, b. about 1871, d. July 21, 1911, m. Mary A. Boggs; Columbia b. and d. 1873.